Milburn plan would end PIP and Universal Credit health top-up for under-25s
Why it hits youNearly a million 16 to 24-year-olds are not in education, work or training, and almost half of them are disabled or in ill health. Benefits for young people cost about £8.1bn a year, and the Resolution Foundation think tank says PIP and the Universal Credit health top-up keep 120,000 young people out of poverty. If the government takes up Milburn's plan, it would change what you could get if you ever became too ill to work before you turn 25.
Alan Milburn, the former Labour health secretary leading the government's review of young people out of work, says under-25s should no longer be able to claim the two main sickness and disability benefits. Instead they'd get a new “youth allowance” and more help to find work. He admits some people would get less money at first. Disability charities want to know who would lose out.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
The Work and Pensions Secretary asked Alan Milburn, a former Labour health secretary, to write an independent report on young people and work. The first part, published in May, looked at why more young disabled people and people with health conditions are not in education, employment or training. GOV.UK ↗
-
Milburn told The Times his final report, due next week, would stop adults under 25 claiming the health element of Universal Credit and Personal Independence Payment (PIP). LBC ↗
-
Instead, young people would get a new “youth allowance”, paid at the same level as the standard rate of Universal Credit. Those who can't work at all because of their disability would get a new benefit paid at a higher rate. The Independent ↗
-
Many young people on PIP would get a new “additional cost allowance” for day-to-day costs linked to their condition. It would not be means-tested or linked to whether they were in work. GB News ↗
-
Milburn admitted that “some people will get less financial support at the beginning of their benefit claim than under the current system.” The Independent ↗
-
About a million young people are not in education, employment or training. Nearly half (45%) are disabled or in ill health. The most common conditions reported by disabled young people in this group are depression, bad nerves or anxiety (23.8%), followed by autism (22.7%). The Guardian ↗
-
Laws on the changes are expected next year. A source told the i Paper that Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden is set to accept Milburn's report in full. The i Paper ↗
-
This is separate from the Conservatives' own £36.1bn benefit cuts plan, set out by Kemi Badenoch this week. The i Paper ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
Alan Milburn and the government
“…this is not about cutting one benefit, it's about rebuilding the system from scratch”
Milburn says today's system “is geared to keeping people inactive”. He told The Times: “What we should do is give young people the best opportunity to earn and learn, rather than immediately going on to a health benefit.” Every young person would get a personal adviser. “The adviser will stick with them until they have found a job or an apprenticeship or college place,” he said. He admits it won't be easy: “I'm not saying that any of this will be easy or that it will be pain-free because it won't.” Last month he told the Guardian: “This is not a workshy, snowflake generation.” Prime Minister Andy Burnham said: “I can't accept the idea that we have a million or more young people in their 20s on benefits. It's not good for them.” A government spokesperson said there would always be “a safety net for the most vulnerable and those who are unable to work.”
- Alan Milburn, review author
- Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
- Government spokesperson
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
What it means for you
Nothing changes yet
These are recommendations from an independent review. They are not law. The full report is due next week, then the government decides what to do. New laws on benefits are expected next year. Under Milburn's plan, as he described it to The Times, under-25s couldn't claim the Universal Credit health top-up or PIP. You'd get a “youth allowance” at the standard Universal Credit rate instead. Many people on PIP would move to an “additional cost allowance” for the extra costs of their condition, which wouldn't depend on your income or whether you work. People who can never be expected to work would get a separate benefit. You'd get a personal adviser, but you could lose some money if you don't take up the support. We don't yet know the exact amounts or who would qualify. Today, PIP helps with extra living costs if you have a long-term physical or mental health condition or disability.
- The Times interview (via the Independent and LBC)
- GOV.UK
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
Disability charities and some MPs
“…some young disabled people could lose out”
Harriet Edwards of the disability charity Sense said it backs more chances to work, but: “We need to understand who will qualify for the new support, who risks missing out, and what practical, accessible help young disabled people will actually receive to find work.” In August, before the details emerged, more than 40 charities wrote to ministers and Milburn. Scope's James Taylor said: “Any cuts to the health element of Universal Credit will only push more young disabled people into poverty, not jobs.” Lucy Schonegevel of Action for Children said the answer was “tailored support and genuinely meaningful job and volunteering opportunities, not sanctions or cuts.” Some Labour MPs are uneasy. One told the i Paper: “I'm also concerned about sanctions; I wouldn't automatically vote for reforms.” From the other side, the Conservatives' Helen Whately said Milburn appeared to be “rolling the pitch for spending more money”.
- Sense
- Scope
- Action for Children
- Labour MPs (anonymous, to the i Paper)
- Helen Whately, Conservative
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Supporters say less about what the evidence shows on rules and sanctions
The plan links benefits to taking up support. The Learning and Work Institute, a research charity, says studies show conditionality and sanctions “can increase short-term exits from benefits and slightly accelerate job entry”, but longer-term results on keeping a job and earnings are “generally negative or minimal”. Charities point out that the Netherlands, often held up as a model, pairs strict rules with much bigger spending on job support, and is itself moving away from stricter approaches.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
PIP isn't an out-of-work benefit, and critics skip the extra-costs debate
Talk of young people “going on to a health benefit” can blur two things. PIP helps with the extra living costs of a condition, whether or not you work; it's the Universal Credit top-up that's linked to being unable to work. On the other side, the Resolution Foundation found around one in five young people on PIP did not have extra costs, so it says some savings are possible, though that's mainly a question for Sir Stephen Timms's separate review of PIP.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Nobody has said how big the bill is
The Resolution Foundation says even matching the average spend of rich countries on job support would cost at least £5bn more a year, and the whole benefits bill for young people is £8.1bn, so cuts alone can't pay for it. Government sources told the Daily Mail that the first money announced next week is likely to be substantially lower than £6bn.
Your Call
- Alan Milburn and the government: not yet
- What it means for you: not yet
- Disability charities and some MPs: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
Hero image: File photo: Nick-D / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Jobcentre Plus office in Wallsend, September 2022 ↗
By No Glaze News · published