UK agrees to slavery talks and a possible apology, but still no reparations
Why it hits youMillions of Africans were enslaved and shipped to British colonies in the Caribbean, and their descendants still live with the consequences. Whether, and how, a country makes up for wrongs done centuries ago is one of the hardest questions in politics. One poll found most 18 to 24-year-olds back talks on it, far more than older people.
The Commonwealth summit in Antigua has ended with the UK agreeing to a “structured, time-bound” dialogue with countries affected by the transatlantic slave trade. King Charles said slavery fills him with “horror” and “profound personal sorrow”, but did not apologise. Prime Minister Andy Burnham is open to a formal apology from the government, which Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband says could come by next November. Britain is putting £40m into Caribbean infrastructure from existing budgets, but still rules out reparations. Caribbean leaders say reparations must be part of the talks. Kemi Badenoch says there should be no apology at all.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
The Commonwealth summit's final statement welcomed the UK's agreement to “a structured, time-bound, inclusive and good-faith dialogue” with those affected by the transatlantic slave trade. The timetable will be agreed later. The Irish News (PA) ↗
-
Opening the summit in Antigua on 3 November, King Charles said the slave trade fills him with “horror” and “the most profound personal sorrow”. He did not apologise; Buckingham Palace had said he would not. Al Jazeera ↗
-
No 10 says the UK will put £40m over three years, from within existing budgets, into critical infrastructure including green energy in the Caribbean. Burnham has ruled out direct reparations. LBC ↗
-
Asked if a formal apology could come by the time the UK hosts the G20 summit in Manchester next November, Ed Miliband said: “Broadly speaking, yes.” The Irish News (PA) ↗
-
Andy Burnham wrote in the Guardian on 30 October that he is open to calls for a formal apology on behalf of the British state, but does not believe British people today can be held liable. The Guardian ↗
-
In 1833 Britain borrowed £20m to compensate slave owners when it abolished slavery. The enslaved people got nothing. The Treasury says the loan was fully paid off in 2015. HM Treasury (GOV.UK) ↗
-
CARICOM's ten-point plan asks for a full formal apology, debt cancellation and programmes on health, education, culture and technology. It also seeks monetary compensation. The Guardian ↗
-
A More in Common poll for the Repair Campaign found 40% of Britons back talks on reparatory justice. Among 18 to 24-year-olds it was 60%. The Guardian ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
Caribbean leaders and campaigners
Progress, but reparations must be in the room
St Lucia's prime minister Philip Pierre, who chairs the Caribbean group of nations CARICOM, said: “No British Prime Minister has gone this far before.” But he added: “A dialogue that begins by placing reparations outside the room cannot be a complete dialogue.” After the summit, Antigua's prime minister Gaston Browne praised Burnham's “courage and goodwill” and said the talks should start within 12 months, adding: “we are very clear on our position that reparations are important”. Ralph Gonsalves, a former prime minister of St Vincent, warned that debt relief and development help are not the same as reparations, because that kind of help is up to the UK to give or not. CARICOM's own plan asks for a formal apology plus debt cancellation, health and education programmes and money. Jamaica has taken its case to the Privy Council.
- Philip Pierre, CARICOM chair
- Gaston Browne, Antigua
- Ralph Gonsalves, Repair Campaign
- CARICOM Reparations Commission
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
The government
Say sorry and talk, but no payouts
Burnham wrote that he wants to express “sorrow and regret” and is open to an apology, but said British people today can't be “held liable for historical wrongs”. Foreign Secretary Ed Miliband said he told partners in advance: “we are willing to say that we’re open to an apology, but we’re not going to shift our position on reparations”. On reparations he added: “It’s not for us. It’s not the right answer. It’s not practical.” He insists taxpayers will not pay a penny more. The UK is giving £40m over three years for Caribbean infrastructure, taken from existing budgets, and wants Gordon Brown to lead a push on debt before the UK hosts the G20 in Manchester next year. A No 10 spokesman said “an apology does not mean accepting present day liability”.
- Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
- Ed Miliband, Foreign Secretary
- Downing Street
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
The Conservatives and Reform
An apology just opens the door to a bill
Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said: “I don't think that Andy Burnham needs to be apologising because it is a lever to wedge open the door to ask for cash.” She also said: “The purpose of the apology is to make us look weak.” She warned of countries “sending us an invoice, which the British taxpayer has (to) pay”. Reform UK's Nigel Farage said: “Britain's already paid the price for its role in the slave trade.” Historian Robert Tombs, on a Spectator podcast, discussed whether Burnham's move risks opening the door to billions in compensation claims. Badenoch also points out that Tony Blair already expressed “deep sorrow” in 2006.
- Kemi Badenoch, Conservatives
- Nigel Farage, Reform UK
- Robert Tombs, historian
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Apology, reparations and aid are three different things
Headlines often lump them together. An apology is words from the government. Reparations means repair paid as of right, which CARICOM's plan says should include debt cancellation and money. Aid, like the £40m from existing budgets, is help the UK chooses to give. Ralph Gonsalves warns that swapping reparations for aid keeps it up to the UK. Antigua's leader has himself suggested reparations could come out of the UK's development budget, which blurs the line too.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Critics skip who got paid in 1833, and what lawyers say
“Britain already paid” is true in one sense: taxpayers repaid the abolition loan until 2015. But that money compensated slave owners, not the people who were enslaved. And on the fear that sorry leads to a bill, a senior former government lawyer told the Guardian: “Simply saying sorry does not give any rights of itself.”
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Campaigners skip where most voters are
Support for talks is strong among young people, but the same poll found it well short of a majority overall, and the poll was commissioned by a campaign for reparations.
Your Call
- Caribbean leaders and campaigners: not yet
- The government: not yet
- The Conservatives and Reform: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
By No Glaze News · published · updated
Next story The UK could pay up to £450m a year so EU students pay the same uni fees as you