Mauricio Pochettino, in a dark blue shirt and trousers, clapping towards a packed stand of USA fans waving flags, with a cameraman beside him on the pitch
File photo: Bryan Berlin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Pochettino at USA v Australia, World Cup, 19 June 2026
FootballCarrick sacked Thursday · Pochettino confirmed Friday, starts 18 Nov · first game at Liverpool, 22 Nov

Man United have made Mauricio Pochettino their new boss. Is he the right man?

Why it hits youUnited are in the relegation zone in November, and he is their eighth permanent manager since Sir Alex Ferguson retired in 2013. Whoever takes over gets one of the biggest jobs in football, but also a club that keeps sacking its managers. In the US, fans are losing a coach who signed up until 2030 just three months ago.

Manchester United sacked Michael Carrick on Thursday with the team 18th in the Premier League. On Friday the club confirmed Mauricio Pochettino, the USA head coach and ex-Spurs, PSG and Chelsea boss, as its new head coach on a two-and-a-half-year deal. Fans of the move say he's an elite manager who United have wanted for years. Doubters say his best days were a decade ago, and that no manager can fix how United is run.

The Facts

What everyone agrees on

Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.

  • Manchester United confirmed on Thursday 12 November that Michael Carrick has left his job as head coach. Manchester United ↗

  • United are 18th in the Premier League, in the relegation zone, after winning only one of their first 10 league games. The Standard ↗

  • Sky Sports reported on Thursday that United and Pochettino had agreed a two-and-a-half-year contract, running to summer 2029. Sky Sports ↗

  • On Friday 13 November, United confirmed that Pochettino will become head coach from 18 November. He has left his job as USA head coach once the Haiti games are over. GB News ↗

  • Pochettino's US contract has a release clause of about $10m (£7.5m). United would pay more to bring his staff, including his assistant of 16 years, Jesús Pérez. The Guardian ↗

  • The USA play Haiti in the Concacaf Nations League quarter-finals on 14 November in Miami and 17 November in Cincinnati. US Soccer ↗

  • Pochettino's record: Spurs finished second in 2016-17 and third in the seasons either side, and reached the 2019 Champions League final. He won Ligue 1 and the French Cup in 18 months at PSG, and spent one season at Chelsea in 2023-24. The Guardian ↗

  • He took the USA job in 2024 and led them to the last 16 of the 2026 World Cup, then signed a new deal running to 2030. The Guardian ↗

Every Side · 1 of 3

The case for Poch

“He's a brilliant coach with great experience and he's a good man”

That's former United captain Gary Neville, who says: “I've always wanted Mauricio Pochettino as manager at [Manchester] United.” The numbers back him up. Of the 20 managers with more than 290 Premier League games, only five legends, including Ferguson, Klopp and Guardiola, have a better points-per-game record. The Guardian's data writer Andrew Beasley puts it simply: “He is an elite manager.” His Spurs side got 86 points in 2016-17 on only the sixth-highest wage bill in English football. The Independent's Miguel Delaney called that “genuine alchemy”. Neville also likes that Pochettino “believes in young players and bringing players through”. One Spurs fan writing to the Guardian said: “I think he's perfect for United right now.”

Who's saying it
  • Gary Neville, ex-United captain
  • Andrew Beasley, the Guardian
  • Miguel Delaney, the Independent

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 2 of 3

What happens next

Two USA games first, then straight to Liverpool

United confirmed on Thursday that Carrick has left. On Friday the club said: “Mauricio Pochettino has agreed to become the Manchester United men's head coach from 18 November.” GB News reports his contract runs until summer 2029. First he'll coach the USA against Haiti twice: in Miami on Saturday 14 November and Cincinnati on Tuesday 17 November, which is the early hours of Wednesday in the UK. Sky says he'll then fly straight to Manchester, take his first training session on Thursday, and face Liverpool at Anfield on Sunday 22 November. United are paying a release clause of about $10m (£7.5m), plus more to bring his long-time staff, including assistant Jesús Pérez.

Who's saying it
  • Manchester United
  • Sky Sports
  • US Soccer

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 3 of 3

The case for doubt

Yesterday's man, joining a club that eats managers

The Guardian's Barney Ronay says “hiring Pochettino is like booking the bloke who did Gangnam Style to play the Super Bowl”, because his best spell was at Spurs about ten years ago. His last Premier League job, at Chelsea in 2023-24, was “a campaign that left more questions than answers”, says Beasley. Others blame the club, not the coach. Neville warns: “if you've got a poor performance department, poor recruitment department, you've not got leadership that is strong right through the spine of the football club, you will fail.” The Manchester United Supporters' Trust says: “Another change of head coach cannot repair what the ownership continues to undermine.” In the US, striker Folarin Balogun said: “If I had a vote, I'd like to keep things the way they are.”

Who's saying it
  • Barney Ronay, the Guardian
  • Manchester United Supporters' Trust
  • Folarin Balogun, USA striker

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Fans of the move skip over Chelsea

Pochettino's only Premier League job in the past six seasons was a year at Chelsea. They finished sixth, about where data firm Opta predicted, despite having the third most valuable squad in the league. They let in 63 league goals, the club's worst in the Premier League era, and he left after one season by mutual agreement.

The Guardian ↗The Guardian (Barney Ronay) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Critics forget how much he did with Spurs

“Past it” arguments rarely mention that his Spurs team got 86 points in 2016-17 with only the sixth-biggest wage bill in England, and reached a Champions League final. Only five managers with 290-plus Premier League games have a better points-per-game record.

The Independent ↗The Guardian ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Who actually chose him?

He wasn't everyone's first pick. The Guardian reports director of football Jason Wilcox wanted Eddie Howe and the recruitment director wanted Julian Nagelsmann. The Daily Mail's Ian Herbert says sources told him the Glazer family pushed for Pochettino. United deny he is a Glazer appointment.

The Guardian ↗Daily Mail ↗

Your Call

Is Mauricio Pochettino the right man to turn Manchester United around?

Which side surprised you most?

Sides you've read
  1. The case for Poch: not yet
  2. What happens next: not yet
  3. The case for doubt: not yet

Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.

Receipts

Every source, one tap away

Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.

Hero image: File photo: Bryan Berlin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 · Pochettino at USA v Australia, World Cup, 19 June 2026 ↗

By No Glaze News · published

Next story Small US study links vaping to weaker lungs, but experts say it can't prove it
Next story