Work & economyRead in full · government backs the job guarantee · benefit changes not decided

Milburn's 278-page plan for young people: what's actually in it

Why it hits youAlmost a million 16 to 24-year-olds aren't in education, work or training, and six in ten of them have never had a job. If you're one of them, or could be, this plan decides what help you'd get, how fast, what you'd be expected to do, and how much money you'd have. Nothing changes yet: the government says young people keep the benefits they get now while it decides. A White Paper is due in the new year, then a new law.

We read all 278 pages of Alan Milburn's review so you don't have to. It promises every young person who isn't working or studying a legal right to a job, course or apprenticeship, with a named adviser within two weeks. In return, young people would have a duty to take part, and those who keep refusing could lose benefits. For under-25s, the health top-up in Universal Credit and Pip would be replaced by a new system, and Milburn admits many would get less cash at first. The government has backed the guarantee and says a paid job will kick in after 12 months out of work, not 18. It hasn't decided on the benefit changes.

The Facts

What everyone agrees on

Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.

  • The review, “From a Welfare State to a Working State”, was published today: 278 pages, with a 36-page summary. Alan Milburn says almost a million 16 to 24-year-olds are not in education, employment or training, most aren't looking for work, and “six in ten have never had a job”. GOV.UK (the review) ↗

  • Milburn wants two legal guarantees for every 18 to 24-year-old who isn't working or studying, whether or not they claim benefits: an Opportunity Guarantee of a route into work, education or training, and a Support Guarantee of help with health and practical problems. The review (summary, p.19) ↗

  • Employers would get £3,000 for hiring a young person who's been out of work or education for six months, £2,000 more for taking on someone facing bigger barriers, such as a care leaver or a disabled young person, and another £2,000 if they have fewer than 50 staff. Milburn says the £1.1bn-a-year package would create 170,000 job and apprenticeship opportunities. The review (full report, ch.3) ↗

  • When “fiscal conditions allow”, Milburn wants employer National Insurance cut over five years for 21 to 24-year-olds, starting in retail and hospitality, by raising the point where it kicks in from £5,000 to £10,000. He says a 21-year-old could then work 15 hours a week on the minimum wage with no employer National Insurance to pay. The review (full report, ch.3) ↗

  • For under-25s, a new Youth Allowance would replace Universal Credit, and the health top-up and the work capability test would go. Pip would be replaced by a new payment for extra costs. The review says “for many the settlement that replaces PIP would pay less cash, at least to begin with”. The review (full report, ch.6) ↗

  • Milburn's figures put the yearly cost at £5.8bn by 2036, offset by £3.6bn of welfare savings and £2.4bn from more tax and fewer benefit claims. He aims for a 5% rate of young people out of work and education by 2036, but says his own modelling gets to about 6.8%. The review (summary, pp.27–28) ↗

  • The government accepted the two guarantees and local delivery. From April, the paid six-month job for young people on Universal Credit will start after 12 months out of work instead of 18. A new Youth Opportunities Unit, chaired by Milburn, will report to the Prime Minister. GOV.UK ↗

  • The government hasn't said what it will do about the Youth Allowance, Pip or sanctions. It will weigh them alongside a separate review of Pip, and publish a White Paper in the new year, followed by a new law. GOV.UK ↗

  • “Young people will continue to receive the benefits and support they are currently eligible for while the government considers the report.” GOV.UK ↗

Every Side · 1 of 3

Milburn, the government and employers

“A deal without consequences is not a deal”

Milburn says the problem isn't lazy young people: “More than seven in ten young people who are NEET want to be in work, education or training.” He blames a system that fails them at every stage, and calls his report “a broad-based manifesto for change” rather than a list of ideas to pick from. He wants employers paid £3,000 to hire someone who's been out of work for six months, plus £2,000 more for small firms and £2,000 more for hiring, say, a care leaver or a disabled young person. In return for a guaranteed offer, young people would have to take part. Sanctions “should be rare and reviewed regularly. But a deal without consequences is not a deal.” Prime Minister Andy Burnham called a million young people out of work or education “an economic and moral catastrophe”. Pat McFadden, the Work and Pensions Secretary, told MPs the government supports the guarantee and local delivery, and will bring the paid-job guarantee forward to 12 months. UKHospitality says the review “has identified the right solutions”.

Who's saying it
  • Alan Milburn, review author
  • Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
  • Pat McFadden, Work and Pensions Secretary
  • Allen Simpson, UKHospitality
  • Andy Spencer, Punch Pubs

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 2 of 3

What it means for you

An adviser in 14 days, a plan in four weeks

If you're 16 to 24 and not working or studying, a new local Youth Opportunity Service would give you a named adviser within 14 days and a written plan within four weeks, whether or not you claim benefits. Within four months you'd have to be doing something: a job, course, apprenticeship, work placement, volunteering or help to start a business. After six months, an employer would get money to hire you. After a year, the state would pay for a six-month job. If you claim, a new Youth Allowance would replace Universal Credit's standard and health payments for under-25s, with a higher rate if you live on your own and a new allowance so part-time work pays. A new payment would replace Pip for under-25s, with a separate, more generous scheme for people with severe, lifelong conditions. None of this is law. The government says young people keep the benefits they get now while it decides, and Milburn wants the new benefit system in place by 2029.

Who's saying it
  • The Milburn review
  • Department for Work and Pensions
  • GOV.UK

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 3 of 3

Opposition, unions, charities and economists

“However they're rebranded, these are still welfare cuts”

That's Andrea Egan of the union Unison. The charity Contact fears “major cuts in financial support for many disabled young people”, and Scope says it is “deeply concerned”. The Resolution Foundation says “the clear losers would include those unable to work due to a health condition”, who would lose a Universal Credit top-up worth £2,600 a year for new claimants. From the other direction, the Conservatives' Helen Whately says the plan “fails to bring down the welfare bill, proposes billions more in government spending” and that “nothing will happen for at least three years”. Reform UK's Suella Braverman says cutting hiring costs is “a glaring admission that Labour's jobs tax has failed”. Lib Dem leader Ed Davey says: “No target or guarantee can conjure up jobs that don't exist.” The Learning and Work Institute warns that finding the money up front “will be a challenge for the Government”.

Who's saying it
  • Andrea Egan, Unison
  • Anna Bird, Contact
  • James Taylor, Scope
  • Resolution Foundation
  • Helen Whately, Conservative
  • Suella Braverman, Reform UK
  • Ed Davey, Liberal Democrats
  • Learning and Work Institute

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Supporters say less about the sums

Milburn's plan only saves money overall in one year, 2036/37, and the review doesn't add up the total cost before then. It says most of the money should come from “a radical reprioritisation” of other spending, without saying what in detail. The report also says its figures “are the Review's estimates, not government spending commitments”. And its own modelling falls short of its 5% target, reaching about 6.8%; Milburn hopes stronger growth will close the gap.

The review (full report, ch.8) ↗Learning and Work Institute ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Critics say less about who gains

Most of the argument is about benefit cuts, but the plan has winners too. The Resolution Foundation says “the biggest winners may well be those already in work”, and that some young people living independently could gain £20 a week if their rate rises to the over-25 level. Under-25s would get a new allowance so part-time work pays, and young people with severe, lifelong conditions would get more than today's maximum. Milburn also says cash help shouldn't be cut before the new support is in place.

Resolution Foundation ↗The review (full report, ch.6) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Past job schemes worked, but weren't cheap

Milburn points to the last two big paid-job schemes, the Future Jobs Fund and Kickstart: for every 100 young people who took part, eleven more were in unsubsidised work two years later than would otherwise have been. Kickstart cost about £7,000 per person, more than twice DWP's next most expensive scheme, and the National Audit Office said the government couldn't show the jobs were “truly additional”, meaning they wouldn't have existed anyway.

The review (full report, ch.6) ↗National Audit Office ↗

Your Call

Is a guaranteed job or course worth losing benefits if you turn it down?

Which side surprised you most?

Sides you've read
  1. Milburn, the government and employers: not yet
  2. What it means for you: not yet
  3. Opposition, unions, charities and economists: not yet

Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.

Receipts

Every source, one tap away

Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.

Official GOV.UKFrom a Welfare State to a Working State: the Milburn review, full report, summary and analytical annex (17 Nov) Official GOV.UKWork and Pensions Secretary's statement to MPs on the Milburn review (17 Nov) Official GOV.UKGovernment commits to new settlement for young people (17 Nov) Official GOV.UKThe independent Young People and Work review: what it means for young people Centre politics.co.uk“A lost generation is not inevitable”: reactions from Helen Whately and Ed Davey Centre LBCMilburn's “Neet zero” review: reactions including Suella Braverman and the Joseph Rowntree Foundation Leans right GB NewsLandmark youth unemployment report suggests Labour's policies are to blame for jobs crisis (17 Nov) Leans right City AM“Complete system reset”: Burnham urged to find “political will” for Milburn's welfare overhaul (16 Nov) Leans left Left Foot ForwardCharities and unions voice deep concern about the review's benefit plans (Unison, Scope, NEF) Leans left Big IssueMilburn review: reactions from the Work Foundation and the Health Foundation (17 Nov) Centre The CatererHospitality bosses back National Insurance cut call from Milburn review (17 Nov) Reference Resolution FoundationGovernment must match Milburn's ambition to properly invest in young people (17 Nov) Reference Learning and Work InstituteResponding to the Milburn review Campaign group ContactContact responds to welfare proposals in Milburn report Fact-check National Audit OfficeEmployment support: the Kickstart scheme (2021)

By No Glaze News · published

Next story Musk, Trump and 165,000 others want Jensen Huang back as Nvidia boss
Next story