Day after Milburn: who's backing his plan, who's worried and what's undecided
Why it hits youIf you're 16 to 24, this plan could decide what help you get, what you're expected to do in return, and how much money you'd have while you look for work. Nothing changes yet. The big decisions, on the tax cut, on replacing Pip and the health part of Universal Credit, and on how much money goes in, come over the next year: in the Budget, the Spending Review, a White Paper in the new year, and then a new law.
Alan Milburn's plan for the almost one million young people not in education, work or training came out on Tuesday. Quick recap: a legal guarantee of a job or training, cash for firms that hire, and a new benefit system for under-25s. A day on, the government is backing the guarantee and promising a college place for every young person. But Prime Minister Andy Burnham won't yet commit to the tax cut for employers. The Conservatives and business groups say the plan grows the state and does too little about the cost of hiring. Unions, economists and some young people worry about benefit cuts and weaker workers' rights.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
Pat McFadden told MPs the government supports Milburn's legal Opportunity and Support Guarantee, will set up a Youth Opportunities Unit reporting to the Prime Minister, and will publish a White Paper in the new year, followed by legislation. GOV.UK ↗
-
Asked on LBC about cutting employer National Insurance for young workers, Burnham said he would look at the evidence and “the affordability of making any change”, but that it was a matter “for the budget more broadly”. The Guardian ↗
-
Right now employers pay no National Insurance on workers under 21 (unless they earn above £50,270), but pay 15% on earnings above £5,000 a year for non-apprentices aged 21 to 24. The Guardian ↗
-
Burnham and McFadden did not explicitly back Milburn's recommendations on National Insurance or zero-hours contracts. The Guardian ↗
-
The government says funding for a guaranteed college place for every young person will start in the 2027/28 academic year. The Independent ↗
-
Milburn's plan would cost £5.8bn a year by 2036-37, paid for by £3.6bn of benefit savings and £2.4bn of extra tax, leaving a saving of about £200m that year. He wants a £500m “downpayment” in the next financial year. The Independent ↗
-
The IFS says the £3.6bn of benefit savings would equal 41% of projected spending on health-related benefits for young people in 2036-37. The Independent ↗
-
McFadden said the Timms review of Pip will be “reporting soon”. GOV.UK ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
The government and its backers
“It's the crude cuts approach, and it just doesn't work”
That's Andy Burnham, speaking to LBC radio, describing what he says the Conservatives and Reform UK would do instead. He said his plan is “not about an arbitrary number for cuts within the system”, and is “a very different proposition” from the welfare cuts Labour MPs blocked last year. Work and Pensions Secretary Pat McFadden told MPs the government backs the legal job-or-training guarantee: “And we support this recommendation.” Some Labour MPs who rebelled last time sound on board. Debbie Abrahams, who chairs the Commons work and pensions committee, called the review “an opportunity of a generation”, adding: “We must change the status quo.” Rachael Maskell welcomed the “ambition”, though she said the “details are yet to be spelt out”. The Guardian's editorial said: “This is not a rerun of failed welfare cuts”. On Tuesday night, Burnham also promised a college place for every young person who wants one: “If you are a young person and want to go to college, we'll make sure you can.”
- Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
- Pat McFadden, Work and Pensions Secretary
- Debbie Abrahams, Labour MP
- Rachael Maskell, Labour MP
- The Guardian (editorial)
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
What's decided and what isn't
The guarantee is a yes. The tax cut and the benefit changes are a maybe
Decided: the government backs a legal guarantee of a job, course or training place for young people who aren't earning or learning, run locally by mayors and councils. A new Youth Opportunities Unit will report straight to the Prime Minister. Colleges will be funded to offer a place to every young person who wants one, starting in the 2027/28 academic year. Not decided: cutting the National Insurance tax employers pay on 21 to 24-year-olds. Burnham said: “I can't give you a firm commitment today because obviously these matters are matters for the budget more broadly.” Also not decided: replacing Pip and the health part of Universal Credit for under-25s, and whether to slow down new workers' rights. McFadden said: “We know that employment costs matter and we will consider all these things as we move forward.” What's next: a separate review of Pip is due soon. Milburn wants £500 million to start with, and wants his plan at the top of next year's Spending Review. The government will publish a White Paper, a detailed plan, in the new year, and then bring in a new law.
- Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
- Pat McFadden, Work and Pensions Secretary
- GOV.UK
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
Opposition, business, unions, economists and young people
Too much state for some. Too many cuts for others
From the right, Conservative leader Kemi Badenoch said: “We don't need costly government schemes to fix Labour's own mistakes.” Shadow chancellor Andrew Griffith said: “You cannot solve a youth jobs emergency without jobs, and this government has spent two years destroying them.” Ryan Shorthouse of the centre-right think tank Bright Blue called it “bigger and bossier government”. Shevaun Haviland of the British Chambers of Commerce said cutting National Insurance for young workers “must happen sooner rather than later, and it should not be sector specific.” The Independent's editorial doubted the plan can create many jobs where there aren't any, and said the job guarantee is “a guarantee of a job for just six months”. From the other side, the Institute for Fiscal Studies (IFS) think tank said “many of those with less severe disabilities would be likely to see large income losses initially”. Rory Bowman, 21, who has autism and got a job as a personal trainer through a year-long work programme, wants young people to keep Pip: “I need that funding more to enter the world of work than I did when I was sat at home playing video games.” Unions are worried about Milburn's doubts over new workers' rights. The TUC's Paul Nowak urged the government to “crack on and deliver its guaranteed hours rights in full”, saying the idea that low-paid insecure work helps young people is “for the birds”.
- Kemi Badenoch, Conservative leader
- Andrew Griffith, Conservative
- Ryan Shorthouse, Bright Blue
- Shevaun Haviland, British Chambers of Commerce
- The Independent (editorial)
- Institute for Fiscal Studies
- Rory Bowman, 21
- Paul Nowak, TUC
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Backers say less about who loses money
The government talks about opportunity, not cuts. But the IFS says people with less severe disabilities could see “large income losses initially”, and even the supportive Guardian editorial warns young people can't be expected to “take it on trust” that new help will replace what they lose.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Critics on the right say less about the sums
The Conservatives call it a costly expansion of the state. But Milburn's plan is meant to roughly pay for itself, saving about £200m a year by 2036-37, and Milburn argues that “crude cuts” without help into work won't work, morally or fiscally.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Tax-cut fans say less about missing jobs
Cheaper hiring only helps if firms are hiring. Job vacancies are at 690,000, the lowest since 2014 outside the pandemic, and the biggest falls were in retail, hospitality and leisure, the very sectors the tax cut would start with.
Your Call
- The government and its backers: not yet
- What's decided and what isn't: not yet
- Opposition, business, unions, economists and young people: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
By No Glaze News · published
Next story Refused asylum seekers could lose their five-day warning before being removed