Travellers walking towards a UK Border passport control area at an airport, under a large blue 'Passport control' sign
File photo: Eric Fischer / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 · Passport control at a UK airport, April 2018
PoliticsDefault wait doubles to 10 years · £50,271+ earners still get 5 · rolls out during 2027

Most migrants will now wait 10 years, not 5, to settle in the UK. Is that fair?

Why it hits youSettling in the UK, known as indefinite leave to remain (ILR), means you can live, work and study here for as long as you like, and claim benefits if you're eligible. The new rules will cover many people who are already here but haven't settled yet. That includes skilled workers who moved here expecting a five-year wait, and international students and graduates whose years on those visas will no longer count.

Home Secretary Shabana Mahmood has confirmed that most people who move to the UK to work will have to wait 10 years, not five, before they can apply to stay for good. High earners and some public service workers can still settle in five, or even three. After a backlash from Labour MPs and cabinet colleagues, she dropped plans to make many care workers wait 15 years. The Conservatives call that a costly U-turn. Migrant groups and business say it is still unfair on people already here.

The Facts

What everyone agrees on

Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.

  • On 2 November the Home Secretary confirmed the final plan: the highest earners can settle within 3 years, people earning more than £50,271 and some public service workers such as doctors, nurses and teachers after 5, and everyone else at a new default of 10 years. Home Office (GOV.UK) ↗

  • It isn't law yet. Mahmood said the changes will start to be laid in the December Immigration Rules and be brought in over the course of 2027. EIN ↗

  • Everyone applying will need a clean criminal record, English to a high standard, no unpaid debt to the taxpayer and at least three years of National Insurance contributions. EIN ↗

  • The climbdown: care workers who arrived before May 2025, met their visa conditions and earned at least £25,000 a year keep a five-year route. Those who didn't, about a quarter, can apply for a new five-year care visa first. Mahmood had earlier proposed a 15-year wait for many of them. PA (via Irish News) ↗

  • Under the original plans, 799,000 people would have had their settlement delayed. Under the final version, the figure is 517,000. The Guardian ↗

  • Time on Student, Graduate, Youth Mobility and other temporary visas won't count towards settlement, and the long residence route, which allowed settlement after 10 years' lawful stay on almost any visa, will close. No closure date has been given. Lewis Silkin ↗

  • Refugees who come through approved safe and legal routes can settle after 5 years. Others wait 20 years, cut to 10 if they work or study. Anyone who arrived by small boat faces an extra 10 years, so up to 30. Home Office (GOV.UK) ↗

  • The public consultation on the plans received 204,667 responses. EIN ↗

Every Side · 1 of 3

The government and the Conservatives

Both back a 10-year wait. They're fighting over who gets let off

Mahmood told MPs: “Settlement should not be automatic; it should be earned.” She said: “Settled status is one of the most valuable rights this country can offer. Until now it has been given almost automatically.” Prime Minister Andy Burnham said it was “only fair that those who are making the most valuable contribution to our communities are given the opportunity to settle earlier”. The Conservatives also want a 10-year wait, but say Mahmood has gone soft. Shadow home secretary Chris Philp called the care worker change a U-turn: “That is the cost of today’s U-turn – £10 billion.” On Wednesday the Conservatives claimed it could add £5.2 billion to the benefits bill. Shadow work and pensions secretary Helen Whately said: “We are not a cash machine for the world.” A Home Office source called that “absurd analysis”, saying half a million people “cannot settle in the next five years because of the action this Government has taken”.

Who's saying it
  • Shabana Mahmood, Home Secretary
  • Andy Burnham, Prime Minister
  • Chris Philp, shadow home secretary
  • Helen Whately, shadow work and pensions secretary

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 2 of 3

Migrant groups, business and some Labour MPs

“It’s changing the goalposts halfway”

That's Dora-Olivia Vicol of the Work Rights Centre, who welcomed the care worker change but said it “remains deeply unfair” that others already here face 10 years. Marley Morris of the IPPR think tank said: “Engineers, chefs and architects are examples of workers who may not necessarily meet high salary thresholds and will still be on a 10-year route to settlement under these new proposals.” The IPPR says skilled migrants due to settle under the current rules would pay in around £115 billion more than they cost over their lifetimes. The Law Society said the change “retrospectively undermines the legal certainty that individuals, families and employers rely on”. Make UK, which represents manufacturers, warned firms would “undoubtedly lose talent to countries that welcome skilled workers rather than moving the goalposts”. Labour MP Stella Creasy said many affected people “don’t claim anyway”.

Who's saying it
  • Work Rights Centre
  • IPPR
  • Law Society
  • Make UK
  • Stella Creasy MP

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 3 of 3

What it means for you

Nothing changes yet, but plan for 10 years

For now, the old rules still apply: most skilled workers can apply to settle after five years. Mahmood said the changes “will begin to be laid from the December Immigration Rules” and roll out “over the course of 2027”. After that, most people will need 10 years, earnings of at least £12,571 a year, English to a high standard, no criminal record, no debts to the government and three years of National Insurance. Earn over £50,271 and it's five years; over £125,141, three. Couples can combine earnings. If you're a student or on a Graduate visa (which lasts at least 18 months, or 3 years after a PhD), that time won't count, and the 10-year “long residence” route, which used to let it count, will close. Children under 18 settle with their parents. Dependants aged 18 to 24 can too without the earnings test, but anyone 25 or over has to qualify on their own. Anyone who already has ILR keeps it.

Who's saying it
  • Home Office (GOV.UK)
  • Lewis Silkin (immigration lawyers)

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Every big number here is a guess about the future

The Conservatives' £5.2 billion assumes people who arrived in the “Boris Wave” would claim Universal Credit at the same rate as settled non-EU migrants did in December 2025, about 32%. The government says its plan saves “billions” but hasn't published a cost; Mahmood says a full impact assessment will come as the rules are brought in. The IPPR's £115 billion is a lifetime estimate too.

Daily Express ↗EIN ↗PA (via Irish News) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

“Students” isn't one group

In March the government banned new study visas for people from Afghanistan, Cameroon, Myanmar and Sudan after asylum claims by students from those countries soared. But 383,455 study visas were granted in the year to June 2026, and most international students come for a master's. The settlement change mainly hits a different group: graduates who stay on to work, whose student and graduate years will no longer count.

Home Office (GOV.UK) ↗Home Office statistics (GOV.UK) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

The Tories' attack leaves out their own record

The Conservatives want a 10-year wait too, but the big rise in legal migration happened under their government, as some Tory MPs admitted. Conservative MP Edward Leigh told Chris Philp that “anybody who was serving as a Home Office minister at that time should wear sackcloth and ashes”.

The Guardian ↗

Your Call

Should most people have to wait 10 years, not 5, to settle in the UK?

Which side surprised you most?

Sides you've read
  1. The government and the Conservatives: not yet
  2. Migrant groups, business and some Labour MPs: not yet
  3. What it means for you: not yet

Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.

Receipts

Every source, one tap away

Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.

Hero image: File photo: Eric Fischer / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 · Passport control at a UK airport, April 2018 ↗

By No Glaze News · published

Next story Chef who refused to put pineapple on pizza lost his case. Not over the pizza
Next story