A ham and pineapple pizza with golden melted cheese, cut into slices on a metal tray
File photo: Elsie Hui / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 · A Hawaiian pizza, October 2014. Not from the restaurant in this story
WorldSacked in May · third pineapple refusal in four years · case thrown out for being filed too late

Chef who refused to put pineapple on pizza lost his case. Not over the pizza

Why it hits youMost of us will one day be asked at work to do something we think is daft, or that clashes with what we believe. This story is funny, but the question underneath it is real: when can your boss insist, and when can you say no? In the UK, the answer depends a lot on how long you've worked there and whether your employer follows a fair process.

Davide Tamburella, an Italian head chef at a restaurant in Brisbane, Australia, refused to make ham and pineapple pizza for a big function, calling it “an insult to his culture”. He was sacked two weeks after a meeting with his boss about that and other complaints. He took the restaurant to Australia's Fair Work Commission, a workplace tribunal. He lost, but only because he filed his claim too late. So nobody has actually ruled on whether the pizza order was fair.

The Facts

What everyone agrees on

Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.

  • Davide Tamburella was sacked from La Costa in Brisbane on 20 May, two weeks after a meeting with boss Elliot Ingram “to address performance concerns”. The Guardian ↗

  • One complaint was that he refused to make ham and pineapple pizza for guests at a function. He said directions from management “need not be followed when it is offensive to his culture”. LBC ↗

  • Tamburella accepted it was the third time he had refused this instruction. The Guardian ↗

  • Bosses also raised his “use of inappropriate language and escalation of the situation during service”. LBC ↗

  • Tamburella claimed his sacking broke Australia's Fair Work Act and was partly because of a workplace injury: he fractured his right hand in two places after hitting a metal handrail. The Guardian ↗

  • Jennifer Hunt of the Fair Work Commission dismissed his claim because it was filed too late and did not meet the test for exceptional circumstances. The Guardian ↗

  • Tamburella was more than three years into applying for a visa that would let him live in Australia permanently, sponsored by his employer. After his sacking he would have to start again. The Guardian ↗

  • La Costa closed in July when its lease ran out. Tamburella now works at another Brisbane restaurant, which doesn't have pineapple on the menu. LBC ↗

Every Side · 1 of 3

The chef and pizza purists

“An insult to his culture”

Tamburella's case, as recorded by the Fair Work Commission, was about principle. He saw putting pineapple on pizza as “an insult to his culture” as an Italian. He told his boss that a direction from management “need not be followed when it is offensive to his culture”, and asked him to “check how important it is for Italians not to put pineapple on a pizza”. Some Italians feel the same. When a famous Naples pizza maker added pineapple to his menu in 2023, one angry post said: “this is not true pizza, let's leave such disgusting additions to the Americans”. Tamburella also argued his sacking was partly linked to a hand injury he got at work.

Who's saying it
  • Davide Tamburella (as recorded by the Fair Work Commission)
  • Italian social media users (via ANSA)

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 2 of 3

The restaurant boss

“More to this story than a pizza topping”

Elliot Ingram, who ran La Costa, says the customer is the point. “We had a large function come in, and they were spending in excess of $15,000, and the guy paying for the whole thing says: ‘Look, I need to get some ham and pineapple pizza,’” he said. Ingram says years in hospitality taught him to “pick your battles”. “Do I go and buy a ham and pineapple pizza? It’s probably not my absolute favourite,” he said. “But I’m not going to turn my nose up at it, that’s for sure.” He also says the pizza was not the only issue: “refusing to follow a management direction relating to a customer request was one of several matters raised during the disciplinary process.”

Who's saying it
  • Elliot Ingram, La Costa managing director

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 3 of 3

What it means for you

If this happened at your Saturday job in the UK

UK law is different from Australia's. Here, the conciliation service Acas says it might be unfair dismissal if you've “worked for their employer for 2 years” and there was no fair reason, the reason wasn't enough, or the employer didn't follow a fair procedure. One fair reason is “misconduct”. Acas says protection will start after 6 months from January 2027, but “is not yet law”. GOV.UK says your employer must show “a valid reason that they can justify” and that they “acted reasonably in the circumstances”. If you're part-time, you can't be treated less favourably than full-time staff. A disciplinary process should include a hearing where you get “a chance to explain your side of the story”, and a chance to appeal. Deadlines matter: Acas says you might only have “3 months minus 1 day” to go to a tribunal.

Who's saying it
  • Acas
  • GOV.UK

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Nobody ruled on the pineapple

Headlines say the chef “lost” over pineapple. In fact the case was thrown out for being late, so the commission never decided whether the pizza order was reasonable or whether his sacking was fair.

The Guardian ↗Adnkronos (via La Milano, Italian) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

It wasn't only about pizza, on either side

The chef's supporters skip the other complaints, including bad language and tension during service, and that this was his third refusal. The restaurant's side skips that he linked his sacking to a hand injury at work, a claim no one has tested.

LBC ↗The Guardian ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Not every Italian chef agrees

In 2023 Gino Sorbillo, one of Italy's most celebrated pizza makers, put pineapple pizza on his menu to fight “food prejudice”. He said: “It's nice, and you can't judge it without first tasting it. There's too much prejudice”.

ANSA ↗The Local Italy ↗

Your Call

Should the chef have just made the pizza?

Which side surprised you most?

Sides you've read
  1. The chef and pizza purists: not yet
  2. The restaurant boss: not yet
  3. What it means for you: not yet

Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.

Receipts

Every source, one tap away

Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.

Hero image: File photo: Elsie Hui / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 · A Hawaiian pizza, October 2014. Not from the restaurant in this story ↗

By No Glaze News · published

Next story England is getting eight new water councils. Will they actually clean up rivers?
Next story