The Houses of Parliament and Big Ben seen across the River Thames, framed by autumn leaves
File photo: Julian Herzog / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 · The Palace of Westminster from the south bank of the Thames, November 2023
PoliticsDraft bill, not yet law · up to 5 years in prison · MPs and peers report by 22 January

A draft law would ban abusive conversion practices. Critics say it goes too far

Why it hits youConversion practices are attempts to “fix” someone for being gay, bi or trans. Everyone in this row says abuse should be illegal. The fight is over where the line sits: who could be investigated, and whether family arguments, workplace rows or religious teaching could end up in court. The bill is still a draft, so the wording can change. If you've been affected, Galop's free helpline is 0800 999 5428.

The government wants to make it a crime to abuse someone in an attempt to change their sexual orientation or transgender identity, where that causes serious harm. LGBT+ charities, psychiatrists and ministers say the law is overdue and has a high bar. Gender-critical groups and a former equalities watchdog chair say the wording is so loose it could catch parents, teachers and company bosses. This week a Telegraph report on bosses and pronouns put the row back in the headlines.

The Facts

What everyone agrees on

Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.

  • The government published the draft Conversion Practices Bill on 25 June 2026. It applies to England and Wales and is going through pre-legislative scrutiny, so it is not yet law. GOV.UK ↗

  • The draft defines a conversion practice as “any conduct” carried out with the intention of causing someone to have or not have, or to believe they have or do not have, a sexual orientation or a transgender identity. Draft bill (GOV.UK) ↗

  • The main offence is carrying out an “abusive conversion practice” that causes “serious harm to the individual's physical or mental health” or “serious alarm or distress” with “a substantial adverse effect on their usual day-to-day activities”. The maximum sentence is 5 years in prison. Draft bill (GOV.UK) ↗

  • Whether conduct is abusive is for the court to decide on all the circumstances. It must consider, among other things, sexual, violent or threatening, or controlling or coercive behaviour, and “economic pressure” or “psychological or emotional pressure”. Draft bill (GOV.UK) ↗

  • The government's notes say serious harm to mental health would be “equivalent to psychiatric injury”, for example PTSD or clinical depression. Explanatory notes (GOV.UK) ↗

  • Health care is outside the offence unless the person acts in a way that “falls far below the standards reasonably expected”, which the notes compare to gross negligence. Explanatory notes (GOV.UK) ↗

  • If an organisation commits the offence, a director, manager or similar officer who “fails to take all reasonable steps to prevent” it also commits the offence. Draft bill (GOV.UK) ↗

  • A joint committee of six MPs and six peers is examining the draft and is due to report by 22 January 2027. Galop ↗

Every Side · 1 of 3

The government and LGBT+ groups

“No-one should face abuse just because of who they are”

That's Olivia Bailey, the equalities minister who launched the draft in June. Her successor, Simon Lightwood, says the bar for prosecution is “deliberately high”: prosecutors must prove intent, abuse and serious harm. He wrote: “Parents will still be able to have difficult and challenging conversations with their children. People will remain free to practise their religion.” The anti-abuse charity Galop said “gaps in legislation have left LGBT+ people unprotected against covert and insidious forms of abuse”. The Royal College of Psychiatrists said it would “strongly support” the draft. Stonewall's Simon Blake said a trans-inclusive ban matters because “it's saying you don't need to be changed, you're good enough”. On pronouns, a government spokesperson said: “Misgendering an employee is not an abusive conversion practice and therefore not touched by our draft Bill.”

Who's saying it
  • Olivia Bailey MP
  • Simon Lightwood, Minister for Equalities
  • Galop
  • Royal College of Psychiatrists
  • Stonewall

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 2 of 3

Gender-critical groups and legal critics

A law that is “ill-conceived” and “unworkable” as written

Baroness Falkner, former chair of the Equality and Human Rights Commission, co-wrote a Policy Exchange report on the draft. She said: “This draft Bill appears oblivious to human rights law in Britain.” Her co-author Akua Reindorf KC said it goes beyond violent “conversion therapy” to include “criminalising good faith conversations between parents and children.” Falkner also warned that bosses must take “all reasonable steps” to prevent an offence, with no list of what those are. Dennis Kavanagh of the Gay Men's Network said: “This bill covers every single workplace I can think of.” He argues the bill doesn't define “abuse”, so a pronoun dispute could lead to a complaint. Helen Joyce of Sex Matters said: “Every organisation in the country should be terrified of the government's draft Conversion Practices Bill.” The Free Speech Union says ministers' promises about parents aren't in the bill, and “a criminal court applies the words of a statute”.

Who's saying it
  • Baroness Falkner (Policy Exchange)
  • Akua Reindorf KC
  • Dennis Kavanagh, Gay Men's Network
  • Helen Joyce, Sex Matters
  • Free Speech Union

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 3 of 3

What it means for you

Not law yet, and it only bites if three tests are met

This is a draft for England and Wales only. For the main crime, a court would need to find three things. First, the person meant to change someone's sexual orientation or transgender identity, or what they believe about it. Second, the conduct was abusive. The court looks at all the circumstances, including violence, threats, control, money pressure, or psychological or emotional pressure. Third, it caused serious harm to physical or mental health, or serious alarm or distress with a “substantial adverse effect” on daily life. Doctors and therapists are covered only if they fall “far below” expected standards. A committee of MPs and peers is taking written evidence until 16 November and must report by 22 January 2027. The government can then change the bill before Parliament votes on it. If you're affected, Galop runs a free conversion practices helpline on 0800 999 5428. Switchboard, the LGBTQIA+ support line, is on 0800 0119 100.

Who's saying it
  • Draft Conversion Practices Bill
  • Explanatory notes
  • Galop
  • Switchboard

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

The pronoun-jail line is a reading, not the wording

The draft never mentions pronouns or misgendering, and the government says misgendering isn't covered. Critics reply that the list of what counts as abuse is open-ended, so they say it can't be ruled out. The headline comes from the Telegraph, which is campaigning for the bill to be scrapped; its report quoted critics and a government spokesperson, but no group that backs the ban.

Draft bill (GOV.UK) ↗The Telegraph (via Yahoo) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Promises about parents aren't in the bill

Ministers say parents, faith leaders and open conversations are safe. But the only written carve-out in the draft is for health care. Everyone else relies on the abuse and harm tests and on ministers' assurances, which a court doesn't have to follow.

Free Speech Union ↗Draft bill (GOV.UK) ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Critics skip how often it still happens

Critics argue serious abuse is already illegal. They say less about Galop's finding that 68% of a sample of its conversion practice cases were current, recent or ongoing, or government research finding 7% of LGBTQ+ people had been offered or undergone conversion practices.

Galop ↗Rayo / heat (Policy Exchange report) ↗

Your Call

Should abusive conversion practices be a crime, and should the law spell out who it doesn't cover?

Which side surprised you most?

Sides you've read
  1. The government and LGBT+ groups: not yet
  2. Gender-critical groups and legal critics: not yet
  3. What it means for you: not yet

Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.

Receipts

Every source, one tap away

Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.

Hero image: File photo: Julian Herzog / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 4.0 · The Palace of Westminster from the south bank of the Thames, November 2023 ↗

By No Glaze News · published

Next story Most migrants will now wait 10 years, not 5, to settle in the UK. Is that fair?
Next story