Phone in your bag at school? From next September, that won't be allowed
Why it hits youIf you're at secondary school in England, your school will probably have to change how it handles phones. Many schools now let you keep your phone in your bag as long as nobody sees or hears it. Under the new rules, you're more likely to lock it in a pouch, put it in a locker or hand it in at the start of the day. The big arguments are over who pays, and whether it actually helps.
Schools in England already have to stop pupils using phones during the school day. Now the government says that keeping your phone switched off in your bag isn't enough. New guidance, starting in September 2027, will tell schools to make phones impossible to reach all day. Education Secretary Lucy Powell says school is for “learning and friendship, not scrolling”. Headteachers' unions say lockable pouches or lockers for every pupil will cost a lot, and they want the government to pay.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
The Department for Education will issue strengthened guidance telling schools in England to make sure phones are inaccessible to pupils throughout the school day, going beyond “not seen, not heard” policies. LBC ↗
-
The strengthened guidance will be introduced from September 2027. The Telegraph (via Yahoo News) ↗
-
The current guidance became statutory on 29 June 2026 and schools had to follow it from 1 September 2026. It says phone use should be banned during lessons, between lessons, at break and at lunch, but doesn't say exactly how to enforce it. GOV.UK ↗
-
Only 16% of secondary pupils say phone rules are followed all of the time, according to a Department for Education survey from June. LBC ↗
-
In the same survey, 62% of secondary school parents said their child's phone must be kept out of sight and not used, while 23% said it had to be handed in or locked away. 78% of secondary parents said they supported their school's phone policy. Department for Education (GOV.UK) ↗
-
Schools will choose how to do it. Some already use lockable pouches or secure storage, some collect phones at the start of the day, and some ban them from the site altogether. The Telegraph (via Yahoo News) ↗
-
The NEU teachers' union says pouches cost about £20 each, so around £20,000 for a school of 1,000 pupils. ASCL says costs could be £20,000 to £40,000 per school. Tes ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
The government and its backers
“Children should not be using smartphones at any point during the school day, full stop”
That's Education Secretary Lucy Powell. She said: “We're backing heads and teachers with a clear message for parents and pupils: school is for learning and friendship, not scrolling.” The Department for Education said schools should go beyond “not seen, not heard”, where phones stay in bags, and “adopt whole-school strategies that keep phones out of use and inaccessible throughout the school day”. Children's Commissioner Dame Rachel de Souza said: “I welcome strong action to stop phones distracting pupils and disrupting the school day.” The Conservatives had pushed for this. Shadow education secretary Laura Trott said: “I am delighted that Labour has finally listened to us and agreed to properly ban smartphones in schools.”
- Lucy Powell, Education Secretary
- Department for Education
- Dame Rachel de Souza, Children's Commissioner
- Laura Trott, Conservatives
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
What it means for you
Your school picks the method, but your phone won't be on you
This is guidance for schools in England, not a new criminal law. Schools already have to stop phone use during lessons, between lessons, at break and at lunch. The change is about how. Schools will choose: some use lockable pouches, some use secure lockers, some collect phones at the start of the day, and some don't allow phones on site at all. Schools can confiscate phones or give detentions if you break the rules. Current guidance says if your parents need to reach you, they should call the school office. It also says schools shouldn't stop you using a phone you need for a medical condition, such as diabetes glucose monitoring, and should be flexible for pupils like young carers. Under current guidance, schools can also let sixth formers use phones at limited times and places, such as a common room.
- Department for Education guidance
- LBC
- The Telegraph
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
Heads' unions and researchers
“This is not feasible unless the Government puts in the funding”
That's Pepe Di'Iasio of the ASCL heads' union. He said: “If all schools are going to be expected to have lockable pouches or other secure storage facilities for every pupil, the cost involved will be very significant indeed.” Paul Whiteman of the NAHT said: “Many schools already have restrictions on phones, but going beyond a ‘not seen, not heard’ approach comes at a cost.” In April, ASCL's Tom Middlehurst told MPs that where “not seen, not heard” already works, it “would seem foolish to have to change that policy”. The Lib Dems' Caroline Voaden backs stronger rules but says “it should be up to headteachers to decide how they keep phones out of reach of pupils”. Researchers at the University of Birmingham say phone policies are “not the silver bullet for addressing attainment, wellbeing or behaviour in schools”.
- Pepe Di'Iasio, ASCL
- Paul Whiteman, NAHT
- Caroline Voaden, Liberal Democrats
- Prof Victoria Goodyear, University of Birmingham
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Supporters skip the mixed evidence
A 2025 University of Birmingham study of 30 English secondary schools found “no evidence” that strict phone policies were linked to better mental wellbeing. A follow-up in 2026 found pupils at strict schools talked to each other more in person, but some said they lost sleep or skipped homework making up for “lost time” on their phones afterwards.
University of Birmingham (Lancet Regional Health – Europe, 2025) ↗University of Birmingham (2026) ↗
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Nobody has said who pays
A national buying deal worth an estimated £60m over eight years has been set up so schools can order phone pouches, but it's a way to buy them, not money to pay for them. In April, Tes reported that only 16% of secondary schools provide lockers to all students.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Critics skip how often the rules are broken
Unions say “not seen, not heard” is fine where it works. But in the government's June survey, only 48% of Year 10 and 11 pupils said pupils at their school had followed the phone rules all or most of the time in the past week.
Your Call
- The government and its backers: not yet
- What it means for you: not yet
- Heads' unions and researchers: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
By No Glaze News · published
Next story Young people are paying for a ‘low-gear economy’, says Bank of England deputy