Harry Kane is set to become England's most-capped man. Is he the greatest ever?
Why it hits youA record that has stood for 36 years is about to fall, and it reopens the oldest argument in English football: do goals, games and individual awards make you the greatest, or do you need to win a trophy with your country?
If Harry Kane plays against Croatia at Wembley tomorrow night, he'll win his 126th England cap and pass goalkeeper Peter Shilton as England's most-capped male player. He's already the record scorer and, two weeks ago, won the Ballon d'Or. Team-mates say he's the best England player ever. Others say that title still belongs to the men who won the World Cup in 1966.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
Kane is set to make his 126th England appearance against Croatia at Wembley on Thursday night, which would take him past Peter Shilton as England's most-capped men's player. The Guardian ↗
-
He drew level with Shilton on 125 caps on 6 October, scoring twice in a 3-0 Nations League win over Czechia at Wembley. Reuters (via The Star) ↗
-
Shilton, a goalkeeper, has held the record since 1990. He took it from Bobby Moore in 1989 and played for England for 20 years. FourFourTwo ↗
-
Kane is England's record scorer with 91 goals. 21 came at major tournaments, and 12 in knockout rounds. The Guardian ↗
-
Kane is in Thomas Tuchel's 25-man squad. The FA says he will become the most-capped England man “should he feature”. England Football (the FA) ↗
-
England v Croatia kicks off at 7.45pm on Thursday 12 November and is live on ITV1. England then play Spain in Madrid on Sunday 15 November. England Football (the FA) ↗
-
Kane's England career began in 2015 against Lithuania, when he scored 79 seconds after coming on as a substitute for Wayne Rooney. The Guardian ↗
-
Fara Williams holds the record for the England women's team, with 172 caps. England Football (the FA) ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
The case for Kane
“He is the best England player to ever wear the shirt”
That's Jude Bellingham, speaking after Kane equalled Shilton's record in October. Kane has 91 England goals, a record, and 21 of them came at major tournaments. Only Cristiano Ronaldo and Kylian Mbappé have scored more at World Cups and Euros among European players. He's 33 and still getting better, winning the Ballon d'Or last month. Manager Thomas Tuchel said: “He deserves the stage, he deserves the praise.” Former Manchester United captain Roy Keane put it more simply: “The guy's a machine.”
- Jude Bellingham
- Thomas Tuchel, England manager
- Roy Keane
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
What it means for you
Thursday, 7.45pm, ITV1. He just has to get on the pitch
England play Croatia at Wembley on Thursday 12 November. Kick-off is 7.45pm and it's live on ITV1. Kane is in the 25-man squad, and the FA says he'll become the most-capped England man “should he feature”. Even coming on as a sub counts. If he misses out, England play Spain in Madrid on Sunday. England also need to avoid defeat to Croatia to be sure of a Nations League quarter-final. For context, the overall England record belongs to a woman: Fara Williams won 172 caps for the Lionesses. Shilton has already sent Kane his blessing, saying he could “set a record that will never be beaten”.
- England Football (the FA)
- Peter Shilton
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
The case for caution
No trophy with England, and more games to play than the greats had
Guardian writer Barney Ronay is a big Kane fan, but says: “Kane is not the greatest ever England player. That will be Bobby Charlton until someone matches his feat of winning the World Cup, European Cup and a Ballon d’Or”. Former England striker Stan Collymore warns of “recency bias”. He points out that older stars played fewer games, as “there weren't the Nations League games, there weren't the number of qualifiers”. He says Kane “just needs” to “finish it off with some silverware”. Ex-Germany midfielder Dietmar Hamann went further: “He didn't play well for England at the European Championship two years ago, and he had problems in the last two knockout matches at the World Cup.”
- Barney Ronay, the Guardian
- Stan Collymore
- Dietmar Hamann
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Kane himself puts trophies first
Fans calling him the greatest rarely mention that Kane has said he would swap all his individual awards for a major trophy with England. Charlton and Moore won the World Cup in 1966. Until Kane wins something with England, many will rank him below them.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
He doesn't only score against small teams
The “more games, easier caps” argument skips Kane's record when it matters. He's scored 14 World Cup goals, 21 at major tournaments and 12 in knockout rounds. Only two European men have scored more at World Cups and Euros combined.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
“Most-capped England player” isn't quite right
Kane is about to become the most-capped England man. The most-capped England player of all is Fara Williams, with 172 caps for the Lionesses between 2001 and her retirement. Even after Thursday, Kane would be 46 caps behind her.
Your Call
- The case for Kane: not yet
- What it means for you: not yet
- The case for caution: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
Hero image: File photo: Bryan Berlin / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY-SA 4.0 · England v Ghana, World Cup, 23 June 2026 ↗
By No Glaze News · published