Could HMRC ask to see your AI tax chats? Only in a tax check, under draft plans
Why it hits youIf you use a chatbot to work out tax on a side hustle, freelance work or a self-employed job, those chats are a written record. If HMRC ever checks your tax return, the working behind your numbers could matter. Unlike talking to a lawyer, a chat with an AI tool has no special legal protection. Nobody is going to trawl your chats for fun, but it's worth knowing what you're typing and checking any figures an AI gives you.
Headlines this week said HMRC could read your ChatGPT history. The truth is narrower. A draft law would widen what counts as a digital record HMRC can ask for, but only when it is already checking someone's tax and the information is “reasonably required”. The draft doesn't mention AI at all. Tax advisers say chats used to work out a tax bill could still be caught. HMRC says it's “not about going through everyone's use of large language models”. Campaigners call it an “overreach”.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
HMRC published draft changes to its information powers on 13 July 2026. They update Schedule 36 of the Finance Act 2008, which lets HMRC send “information notices”, and section 114, which covers computer records. HMRC (GOV.UK) ↗
-
The draft renames section 114 “Digital information” and swaps “any computer and any associated apparatus or material” for “anything”. It also lets HMRC ask for help from “any person who created, developed or produced that thing”. HMRC draft legislation (GOV.UK) ↗
-
The draft doesn't mention artificial intelligence, chatbots or large language models. The link to AI chats comes from tax advisers reading the wider wording. Tax Dispute Solicitors ↗
-
HMRC says the changes “do not create a new standalone information power”. They only apply where HMRC already has a lawful basis to ask for information, and it must still be “reasonably required to check a tax position”. HMRC policy note (GOV.UK) ↗
-
It isn't law yet. The changes are due to take effect when the Finance Bill 2026-27 gets Royal Assent. HMRC policy note (GOV.UK) ↗
-
If you don't comply with an information notice, HMRC can charge £300, then up to £60 a day. Giving inaccurate information carelessly or deliberately can cost up to £3,000 per mistake. These penalties already exist and aren't new. HMRC factsheet CC/FS2 (GOV.UK) ↗
-
HMRC can't use an information notice to ask for things you don't have and can't get, or for privileged communications between lawyers and clients about legal advice. HMRC factsheet CC/FS2 (GOV.UK) ↗
-
In a 2026 survey by the Administrative Burdens Advisory Board, 32.4% of respondents said they had used a generative AI system such as ChatGPT or Copilot to answer a tax query. Tax Dispute Solicitors ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
HMRC and some tax experts
“It is not about going through everyone's use of large language models”
An HMRC spokesperson said: “This is about updating our existing information powers to reflect how tax information is now stored and processed digitally. It is not about going through everyone's use of large language models. We can only request information where we already have a lawful basis to do so.” HMRC says the change aims to “keep the tax system fair and effective” by making sure it can check digital tax records, and to help tackle evasion. Seb Maley of tax insurer Qdos said HMRC “wants to know not just what tax figure a system produces, but how it arrived at that number.” Financial adviser Zoe Dagless said: “I certainly don't think HMRC are going to start checking everyone's digital footprint.”
- HMRC
- Seb Maley, Qdos
- Zoe Dagless, financial adviser
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
What it means for you
Your chats aren't private like a lawyer's advice
HMRC can only use these powers when it is checking someone's tax, and the information must be needed for that. Tax lawyers at Tax Dispute Solicitors put it simply: “HMRC cannot demand your ChatGPT history just because it exists.” But they also point out that “an AI tool is not a lawyer or a person appointed to give tax advice”, so your chats don't get the protection that conversations with a lawyer do. They warn: “do not clear the history in response to the proposed changes”, because destroying records HMRC asks for can be punished. Adviser David Stirling said: “If your chatbot helped calculate your tax bill, assume the workings could one day be scrutinised, so don't type anything you wouldn't fancy explaining to the taxman.” Landlord site Property118 says to treat AI tools as aids “not as a substitute for checking the figures”.
- Tax Dispute Solicitors
- David Stirling, Mint Wealth
- Property118
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
Campaigners and tax lawyers
“Ministers must rein in the tax authority”
Anne Strickland of the TaxPayers' Alliance, which campaigns for lower taxes, said: “HMRC already has sweeping powers, and expanding them further risks trampling over the privacy of ordinary Britons. Ministers must rein in the tax authority and ensure that this never becomes implemented.” Matthew Holman, a partner at law firm Cripps, warned that chatting with AI is open-ended, so “it is not challenging to imagine that a discussion with a sophisticated large language model about an individual's tax affairs could easily (and unintentionally) contain content later used to allege intention to evade tax.” Nimesh Shah of accountants Blick Rothenberg said: “The challenge will be ensuring that these powers remain proportionate.”
- TaxPayers' Alliance
- Matthew Holman, Cripps
- Nimesh Shah, Blick Rothenberg
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
The scariest headlines skip the small print
Several reports said HMRC could read your ChatGPT history. Property118 says that wording “gives a misleading impression”: the proposal “does not create a general power for HMRC to browse a person's AI account”, and HMRC still needs a lawful reason in a specific tax check.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
HMRC hasn't said how far “anything” reaches
HMRC's reassurances don't explain how the new “created, developed or produced” wording would apply to AI companies. Matthew Holman of law firm Cripps said the Bill isn't “explicitly enabling access to AI history” but expands its definitions “in such a way that AI could be within its new (wider) scope.”
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Critics skip what HMRC can already do
HMRC can already ask for computer records in a tax check, and the £300 and £3,000 penalties being quoted aren't new. The change mostly updates wording for digital records rather than creating a brand-new power.
Your Call
- HMRC and some tax experts: not yet
- What it means for you: not yet
- Campaigners and tax lawyers: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
By No Glaze News · published