A tarot reader wants £12.7m over a broken cinema seat. Vue says £12,500, tops
Why it hits youAnyone can get hurt somewhere that isn't looked after properly, like a cinema, shop or gym. This case shows how compensation for an injury is actually worked out, and why the eye-catching number in a headline is what someone is asking for, not what a court has given them.
Marcus Hunefalk-Franzen, a 60-year-old tarot reader and actor from Camden, says a seat at Vue's cinema in Islington, north London, collapsed as he got up at the end of a film in 2015, throwing him into the row in front. Vue has admitted liability, which means it accepts it is legally responsible for the accident. What it disputes is how much that's worth. He now values his claim at £12.7m, mostly for earnings he says he lost, including from a planned online psychic business. Vue's lawyers say it's worth £8,000 to £12,500. Nothing has been decided yet: the trial isn't expected until the end of 2027.
The Facts
What everyone agrees on
Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.
-
Central London County Court heard that Hunefalk-Franzen was watching a matinee at Vue's Islington cinema in September 2015 when his seat collapsed as he got up at the end of the film. The Independent ↗
-
Vue Entertainment Ltd has admitted liability for the accident. The fight is over how much compensation it should pay. The Mirror ↗
-
He first valued the claim at £50,000, then £200,000. Legal papers now put it at £12.7m. The Independent ↗
-
Most of the £12.7m is for lost earnings: more than £1.5m he says he has already lost, and over £10m in future earnings. The Independent ↗
-
He is also claiming more than £12,000 for past holidays, listed as “respite travel”, and thousands of pounds for 15 years' worth of orthopaedic shoes. The Independent ↗
-
At a hearing in 2024, Vue's barrister said the claim was worth between £8,000 and £12,500. Vue still holds that position. The Independent ↗
-
The trial was meant to happen by February 2025 at the latest. It is now not expected until the end of 2027. He is representing himself. Daily Mail ↗
-
At a pre-trial hearing this week, Judge Alan Saggarson refused to let him rely on a revised pain expert's report because he had missed the deadline. Daily Mail ↗
Every Side · 1 of 3
His case, as he tells it
“The circumstances speak for themselves”
Hunefalk-Franzen's court papers say that as he got up, “the chair collapsed in on itself and catapulted the claimant forward into the chair in front”. They add: “It was later discovered that bolts anchoring the chair to the floor were missing, causing the chair to overturn.” He claims the seat was “dangerously defective” and, in legal terms, a “trap”. He says he was left with whiplash, chronic neck and back pain, and damaged hearing, taste and smell. In 2024 he told a judge he was only now “managing to start walking without a stick”. At the time he was reading tarot at Greenwich market, building an online presence and acting. He claims his plans, including an acting coaching business and an online psychic platform called MyPsychicEye, would already have earned him more than £1.5m, and that MyPsychicEye would now earn over £1m a year. He is representing himself in court.
- Marcus Hunefalk-Franzen (via court documents and hearings)
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 2 of 3
Vue's lawyers and the court
An injury, yes. £12.7m, no
Vue accepts the accident was its responsibility, but not his figure. In 2024 its barrister, David White, said the claim was worth between £8,000 and £12,500, and Vue still says so. White said he had probably suffered a whiplash-type injury, but that the medical evidence “does not support the hearing loss or taste loss being attributable to this accident”. Vue's written defence says his medical records show “a significant pre-existing history of symptoms including fibromyalgia and chronic fatigue syndrome dating back to 2008 and neck pain dating back to 2009”. It says he reported a back injury on the day, but adds: “There was no mention of immediate severe pain in the neck”. This week Judge Alan Saggarson refused to let him use an updated pain expert's report because he'd missed a deadline. “Litigants in person are not to be given any special treatment,” the judge said, though he added: “The claimant's action remains firmly on track.”
- David White, barrister for Vue
- Vue's written defence
- Judge Alan Saggarson
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
Every Side · 3 of 3
What it means for you
How injury claims like this work
Compensation for an injury usually has two parts. The charity Advicenow explains the first covers “your pain, suffering and how your life has been affected”, which is “What lawyers call ‘general damages’”. Judges value it using the “Judicial College Guidelines”, which give a range for each kind of injury. The second part is extra costs and lost earnings: “What lawyers call ‘special damages’”. That's where big figures come from, because you can claim money you say you would have earned. But “you will need to prove the amounts you lost”, for example with payslips or accounts. Time limits matter. Citizens Advice says for most injury claims, “court proceedings must be issued within 3 years of you first being aware that you have suffered an injury”. Small injuries not caused by road accidents, worth under £1,500, usually count as a small claim. GOV.UK says “You have the right to speak for yourself in court without a solicitor”, but Citizens Advice says to get advice early. On a conditional fee (“no win, no fee”) deal, Citizens Advice says “your solicitor will receive no fees if you lose your case”.
- Advicenow
- Citizens Advice
- GOV.UK
Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Asking for £12.7m isn't winning £12.7m
The headline figure is his own valuation, and nothing has been tried yet. Vue says the claim is worth £8,000 to £12,500. Lost earnings have to be proved with evidence such as payslips, accounts and tax returns, and the injury itself is valued by judges using set guidelines.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Vue has already accepted the accident was its fault
Jokes about the “psychic” claim skip a basic point: Vue admitted liability, and its own barrister accepted he had probably suffered a whiplash-type injury. The argument is about which of his health problems the fall caused, and what they cost him.
The Blindspot · what the headlines skip
Twelve years from accident to trial
Few reports dwell on why it's taking so long. He is representing himself, and a judge said he “suffers from a constellation of difficulties relating to his cognitive ability and concentration”. Court rules for injury claims aim to help both sides settle before ever reaching court.
Your Call
- His case, as he tells it: not yet
- Vue's lawyers and the court: not yet
- What it means for you: not yet
Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.
Receipts
Every source, one tap away
Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.
By No Glaze News · published