A tall concrete office tower with rows of narrow windows and an overhanging top floor, framed by green leaves and branches against a clear blue sky, with a red-brick building in the bottom left
File photo: Matt Brown / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 · Ministry of Justice building, 102 Petty France, London, May 2023
Crime & justiceConsultation open until 24 Dec · England and Wales only · not law yet

Some crimes from when you were under 18 could stop following you for life

Why it hits youA criminal record check can decide whether you get a job, a uni place on some courses, or a volunteering role. Right now, many convictions from when you were 15, 16 or 17 have to be disclosed for the rest of your life on the more detailed checks used for sensitive jobs. The Ministry of Justice says England and Wales have some of the strictest rules of any comparable country. If these plans become law, someone convicted of robbery at 16 who never offends again would only have it show on those checks for five and a half years, not forever.

The government wants to change the rules on criminal records for offences people were convicted of as children. Some convictions, including robbery, affray and actual bodily harm, would no longer have to be shown to employers for life on the checks used for jobs like teaching and care work. Fines and out-of-court punishments given to under-18s could stop needing to be disclosed sooner, or at all. Serious violent and sexual offences would still always be disclosed. It's a consultation, so nothing has changed yet.

The Facts

What everyone agrees on

Before anyone spins it. Every one of these is checkable.

  • The Ministry of Justice launched a consultation on reforming childhood criminal records on 12 November 2026. It applies to England and Wales and closes at 11:59pm on 24 December 2026. GOV.UK ↗

  • The plans would take five offences off the list that must always be disclosed when someone was convicted as a child: affray, violent disorder, supplying drugs to a child under 16, robbery and assault occasioning actual bodily harm. Without a custodial sentence, they'd show on standard and enhanced checks for five and a half years. GOV.UK ↗

  • Childhood convictions that led to a custodial sentence of two years or less would be disclosed for 11 years instead of for life. Anyone given a longer custodial sentence would still have to disclose it for life. LBC ↗

  • The government also proposes cutting the time a childhood fine has to be disclosed from six months to three months or none at all, ending automatic disclosure of any out-of-court resolution, and scrapping the ‘drag-on’ rule, which keeps an earlier conviction unspent if you're convicted again. GOV.UK ↗

  • The most serious offences, including violent, terrorism-related and sexual offences, would still have to be disclosed for life. The consultation does not propose any changes to the Disclosure and Barring Service's barring scheme, which stops people who pose a risk working with children or vulnerable adults. Any changes would need new laws “when parliamentary time allows”. GOV.UK ↗

  • Between November 2023 and April 2026, 7,291 standard and 36,476 enhanced DBS certificates disclosed childhood offences. Over 85% of those convictions were for offences committed between the ages of 15 and 17. Over the last three years, around 76% of childhood offences disclosed were committed over 20 years ago. GOV.UK ↗

  • Records would not be deleted. Criminal records are kept on the Police National Computer until the person is 100 years old. A spent conviction is still on the record, but in most cases you don't have to disclose it. GOV.UK ↗

  • The minister has ruled out raising the age of criminal responsibility, which stays at 10. Some campaigners have called for it to be raised to between 12 and 14. LBC ↗

Every Side · 1 of 3

The government and reform campaigners

“…those who turn their lives around shouldn’t be condemned to carry their mistakes forever”

Jake Richards, the minister for youth justice, said: “Children who commit crimes must face the consequences. But those who turn their lives around shouldn’t be condemned to carry their mistakes forever.” He added: “Too often, a childhood criminal record can close doors to jobs, education and the chance to build a better future.” He told LBC the current system “really doesn't differentiate between crimes committed as an adult and those crimes committed as often really young children”, adding: “And I think most people would think that's just not fair.” Paula Harriott, chief executive of the charity Unlock, said: “It is not proportionate or fair that each year tens of thousands of people have to disclose childhood offences that are irrelevant to who they are today.” Penelope Gibbs of Transform Justice said a child who gets a community sentence at 12 “will often still have to disclose that offence thirty years later. Even if they have led a crime free life for all those 30 years.” A 22-year-old who spent 18 months in a young offender institution, speaking to the Guardian under a false name, said: “If my criminal record from five and a half years ago was gone now, I would be able to achieve my dreams, literally”.

Who's saying it
  • Jake Richards, justice minister
  • Paula Harriott, Unlock
  • Penelope Gibbs, Transform Justice
  • Joanne (not her real name), 22, via the Guardian

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 2 of 3

What it means for you

Nothing changes yet, and your record isn't wiped

These are proposals. They'd need a new law, and the government says that will come “when parliamentary time allows”. They only cover England and Wales. There are two kinds of check. A basic check can be used for any job, and only shows convictions that aren't yet “spent”. Standard and enhanced checks are for sensitive jobs, like teaching, care, nursing, law or taxi driving, and can show older convictions too. Under the plans, five offences committed as a child (robbery, affray, violent disorder, actual bodily harm and supplying drugs to under-16s) would show on these checks for five and a half years, not for life, as long as you weren't given custody. A custodial sentence of two years or less would show for 11 years instead of for life. A fine would become spent after three months or straight away, instead of six months. Cautions and other out-of-court outcomes wouldn't have to be disclosed automatically. Your record itself stays on the police computer. If you want to have your say, the consultation is open until 11:59pm on 24 December.

Who's saying it
  • Ministry of Justice consultation
  • LBC
  • The Guardian

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

Every Side · 3 of 3

Safeguarding worries and the Conservatives

“There are many crimes so serious that they should always be disclosed”

Even ministers stress there are limits. Satvir Kaur, the safeguarding minister, said: “There are some convictions, particularly for serious violent and sexual offences, that will always need to be disclosed. We are going further to strengthen these safeguards.” She added that protecting communities “will always be at the heart of our decision-making”. The government's own consultation admits one change is risky. On taking drug supply to under-16s off the list, it says “there may be safeguarding implications”, especially with county lines, where under-18s can be “deliberately used to target children to sell drugs to”. When the idea was first reported last December, Chris Philp, then the Conservatives' shadow home secretary, said: “Employers and others are entitled to know about previous serious offending by under 18s if it might be relevant. The length of time that has passed and the seriousness of the offence should be taken into account. There are many crimes so serious that they should always be disclosed.” We couldn't find a fresh response from the Conservatives or from victims' groups to this week's plans.

Who's saying it
  • Satvir Kaur, safeguarding minister
  • Ministry of Justice consultation
  • Chris Philp, Conservative (December 2025)

Side labels are our editorial calls for now. How we'll rate lean

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

It's your age when you're convicted that counts, not when you did it

The plans are sold as help for “childhood” offences. But the rules go by your age on the day you're convicted. If you commit an offence at 17 and the case reaches court after you turn 18, adult disclosure periods apply. The government says there are “multiple operational barriers” to changing this, but that it is “currently reviewing whether more can be done”. The Standing Committee for Youth Justice was already calling for this to be fixed in 2020.

GOV.UK ↗Standing Committee for Youth Justice ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

“Wiped” headlines skip travel and visas

Some coverage talks about records being “wiped”. They aren't. Your record stays on the police computer until you're 100. And these rules are about what employers can see. The charity Unlock says visa applications, for places like the USA and Australia, are exempt from the Rehabilitation of Offenders Act, so you'd need to disclose both spent and unspent convictions. Nothing in the plans changes that.

Unlock ↗The Mirror ↗

The Blindspot · what the headlines skip

Scotland has its own rules, and has gone further on paper

These plans are for England and Wales only. Scotland runs its own system through Disclosure Scotland. The Scottish Government's Disclosure (Scotland) Bill included a plan to end automatic disclosure of convictions for offences committed under 18. Instead, Disclosure Scotland would assess each case first, with the chance of an independent review. And if you're applying to uni, Unlock says UCAS hasn't asked about unspent convictions for most courses since 2019. It only asks for courses leading to jobs where you'd work with children or vulnerable adults, which are the jobs that use the stricter checks these reforms are about.

Scottish Government ↗Unlock ↗

Your Call

Should a conviction from when you were 16 still show up on job checks when you're 40?

Which side surprised you most?

Sides you've read
  1. The government and reform campaigners: not yet
  2. What it means for you: not yet
  3. Safeguarding worries and the Conservatives: not yet

Only you can see this. It's saved on this device and never sent anywhere.

Receipts

Every source, one tap away

Don't take our word for it. This is everything the breakdown is built on.

Hero image: File photo: Matt Brown / Wikimedia Commons, CC BY 2.0 · Ministry of Justice building, 102 Petty France, London, May 2023 ↗

By No Glaze News · published

Next story Global Microsoft outage hits Teams and Outlook as fix starts to show results
Next story